Direct requests or marketplaces? A practical comparison for Gudauri ski schools and Kazbegi horse tours
A Gudauri ski instructor needs people who want lessons. A Kazbegi stable needs guests who can arrive at the meeting point and ride safely. In both cases, there are two different jobs: helping travellers discover the activity and making it easy for interested guests to ask for a place. Marketplaces may help with the first job. Your own website can help with the second. Neither channel guarantees sales.
How a marketplace works
A marketplace such as GetYourGuide lists activities alongside alternatives. Travellers can compare schedules, descriptions, photos and reviews before placing a booking. The platform generally handles parts of the reservation and payment process, under its terms. For a business without its own audience, that exposure can be useful. Competition also appears beside your offer, and the platform controls much of the shopping experience.
For suppliers, GetYourGuide says listing and maintaining activities is free and that commission is charged on successful bookings. It does not publish one universal commission percentage, so the rate that counts is the one in your own agreement. Review the actual supplier agreement, cancellation rules, payout timing and any payment adjustments before deciding whether a listing is profitable.
What a direct booking-request page does
Your own page has a different purpose. A guest sees your activities, prices, durations, meeting points and available choices. They select the activity, preferred date and number of people, then send a structured request to your WhatsApp. You confirm capacity, weather conditions and the final arrangement yourself. You also collect payment directly using your own method. A request is not an automatically confirmed or paid reservation.
With Melanvi, the page is set up and maintained for the owner in Georgian, Russian and English, with no commission charged by Melanvi. For tours and activities the plans are Basic 29, Pro 49 and Full care 79 USD a month; guesthouses pay 69, 98 or 249 USD a year. Plans renew by themselves every month (or year) and can be cancelled any time in PayPal. The owner sees a free preview before paying anything. These charges pay for the page service, not for advertisements, guaranteed search ranking or customer acquisition. Payment-provider charges and the owner's time are separate costs.
Compare costs using your real numbers
Suppose a riding tour sells for US$100 equivalent. Every 10 percentage points of marketplace fee is US$10 on one completed booking and US$100 across ten such bookings. This article does not state a rate for GetYourGuide or any other platform: take the percentage from your own supplier agreement, including any modifiers, and do the sum with that.
A monthly page plan (Pro, for example, is US$49) stays the same for that month whether you received zero, two or ten direct requests. But a request that does not turn into a paid tour has no revenue. Also include website promotion, card fees if you use them, telephone time, taxes and cancellations. Comparing “commission per booking” with “fixed monthly page cost” without comparing actual sources of customers can mislead you.
Which channel fits which situation?
A new ski school with no recognised name may value marketplace discovery, provided the fees and rules work for its margins. An established school with repeat students, a Google Maps listing and word-of-mouth enquiries may find a direct page useful for handling people who already know its name. It can list private lessons, age and ability requirements, equipment exclusions and exact meeting options without making guests send a vague message.
A Kazbegi horse-tour operator should pay particular attention to weather, rider experience, minimum age, route changes and available horses. A request-and-confirm model can be more appropriate than instant confirmation when these factors need human checking. A marketplace may still be worthwhile for visitors who otherwise would not know the stable exists.
Using both without creating confusion
Keep marketplace reservations on the marketplace under its rules. Do not try to move customers away from an existing platform booking if the contract prohibits that. Separately, use your website URL in places you control: your own business profile's website field, Instagram bio, printed QR cards and replies to direct enquiries. Keep prices and inclusions consistent or clearly explain differences.
Measure each channel monthly: completed paid tours, gross receipts, marketplace charges, direct page fees, refunds and the time spent answering messages. Judge profit and workload, not just the number of enquiries. A useful channel mix can change between winter in Gudauri and summer in Kazbegi.
If you want to see how a direct request would work for your specific activities, Melanvi can prepare a free preview with your real prices and photos, with no obligation to continue.
Next: what a good tour page shows, so guests can judge your offer next to any marketplace.